Sitare Zameen Par vs Campeones MOVIE REVIEW| Girish

Sitare Zameen Par, Aamir Khan’s 2025 movie, is an Indian adaptation of the Spanish film Campeones. As a Hindi remake of Campeones, it tries to carry forward the heart and soul of the original while tailoring it to the Bollywood audience. But does it succeed?

As someone who enjoys inclusive cinema and inspiring movies based on disabilities, I was curious to see how this Bollywood remake of Campeones would play out. While the intent is noble and the message important, the overall execution felt somewhat dramatized and less organic than the original.

Campeones is a beautiful example of subtle storytelling. It thrives on genuine performances and a grounded narrative. Every laugh and every tear felt earned. In contrast, Sitare Zameen Par leans into melodrama, trying a little too hard to make the audience feel.

This emotional Bollywood drama certainly has its high points. Aamir Khan is charismatic as always, and the supporting cast gives decent performances. The film has moments that will make you smile, moments that will move you, and moments that feel a bit stretched.

As an inspiring movie based on disabilities, Campeones set a high bar. It normalized neurodivergence without pity or preachiness. Sitare Zameen Par, on the other hand, often frames the characters with a lens of sympathy, which slightly undercuts the message of inclusion.

That said, the film is not without merit. If you haven’t seen Campeones, you might actually enjoy Sitare Zameen Par as a standalone movie. It’s got heart, humor, and a dash of Bollywood flair. But if you’ve seen the original, the comparisons are inevitable—and not always flattering.

Would I watch Sitare Zameen Par again? Honestly, not alone. It doesn’t have that rewatchable charm. But if I were with someone—maybe introducing them to the topic of inclusive sports or differently-abled athletes—I’d consider watching it with them.

My Final Rating: 3.5 out of 5

This review is part of my collection of inclusive cinema reviews—films that try to do more than just entertain. While Sitare Zameen Par doesn’t quite reach the emotional depth of Campeones, it’s still a well-intentioned effort that deserves one viewing.

Watch The Full Review:

Click play on the video above to watch my full review. I break down how both films approach storytelling, character arcs, and emotional depth. It's not just a Campeones movie comparison; it’s a reflection on how stories change when they cross cultures.

Conclusion:

Both films aim to inspire and celebrate human potential. But where Campeones connects through simplicity and realness, Sitare Zameen Par sometimes tries too hard to be heartfelt. Still, as an emotional Bollywood drama, it has a place. And as a viewer who appreciates inspiring movies based on disabilities, I recognize the attempt—however imperfect it might be.

Let me know what you think. Did Sitare Zameen Par move you more than Campeones? Would you watch it again?